felinejumper: Rachel Weisz as Sarah Churchill in The Favourite, surpised by a blood spatter on her face (favourite)
felinejumper ([personal profile] felinejumper) wrote2020-04-18 02:15 pm

magnus archives x sarah waters/affinity

one of those aten't dead things, hi, god, how are we all doing? Bad, I assume, I wouldn't know because if I think about it too hard I will stop functioning and this bitch is an essential worker (not the direct-patient kind, though). Have we thought about how taboo it will be to kiss another person in [some number] of months?

Anyway, I listened to the entirety of season 1 of The Magnus Archives over the past week, and wow fuck did I love it. Meta archival narrative? Self-deception? The translation between mediums? Dubious record keeping? Fickle memory? The things that live in the cracks of the world?! A deep voiced British academic with big skepticism vibes being mean!?! I have been swooning and getting chills in equal measure.

I'm on season two (translation: I am 10 minutes into the first episode), and Millbank Prison has come up for reasons, and now I'm just...obsessing over Sarah Waters and Affinity and the para/normal dis/belief &first person narrative dubiousness, of both stories. I love that I already have fictional context for Millbank, as it deeply adds to the contextually skin-crawling creep vibes. I just!!! I don't wanna spoil stuff but I want this fic to exist (I always want the fic to exist). Like -- Jonathan Sims reading me an excerpt from Affinity, sort've vibes. The overlap is just...just there and I so hope it gets more fodder, tangential as it might be.

Perhaps my Affinity fix it is just...The Magnus Archives? Oh boy, I feel genuinely great about that.

rydra_wong: Rickety shelves covered in books, stretching back towards a yellow door (archives)

[personal profile] rydra_wong 2020-04-19 10:03 am (UTC)(link)
*sidles in*

Hiiiiiii. I'm afraid I have absolutely no memory of what context I first encountered you in (Black Sails, possibly?) but hiiii, you're talking about The Magnus Archives, hi.

It's SO fucking good (I am up to speed and being flattened by the new eps on a weekly basis, it's great).
rydra_wong: Cassette tape with "statement begins" and "statement ends" around it (statement begins)

[personal profile] rydra_wong 2020-04-19 05:30 pm (UTC)(link)
There's definitely an influx of people from Black Sails fandom coming into Magnus Archives fandom right now -- there are multiple possible reasons I can think of, but (without wishing to be spoilery) I think one is a certain resemblance in narrative sensibility. Not sure I can articulate what that is yet, but there's something there.

I was so happy when I listened to the little q&a between s1/s2 and realized I had dependable storytellers coming thru.

Yessss, love their commitment to having an actual ending, and knowing the answers to your mysteries if you're spinning a grand meta-plot (and their thoughtfulness about narrative in general, e.g. things like mystery/horror and what makes them satisfying, answers versus the unknown).

There's a Patreon interview featuring Alex Newall ripping the shit out of -- can't remember if he namechecks it specifically, but it's certainly the "mystery box" mode of storytelling he's referring to: "It is an UNSUSTAINABLE NARRATIVE MODEL!"

The progressive reveals in TMA (including the initial reveal that there is a meta-plot and this isn't just a frame for an anthology) have been handled so beautifully.

And at this point I'm very hopeful that they're going to stick the landing. Very little idea what the ending will be, but high hopes that it'll be properly cathartic and satisfying. I may be disappointed, but I am on for the ride.
sea_changed: Close-up of the face of Anne Bonny from Black Sails (Default)

[personal profile] sea_changed 2020-05-07 10:45 pm (UTC)(link)
I have also been thinking about the potential for Affinity/Magnus Archives crossover madness, so this was a wonderfully serendipitous post. I don't know how it would work out really, but the parallel settings and unsettlingness and the power and danger of people testifying/telling their stories--it really is something, isn't it.